🥘🍔🍛🍜🌯🍕
Papa Johns Pizza, Shelbyville, IN — Order Delivery & Takeout.
Closed. Opens at 2:00 PM
Papa Johns Pizza
510 E Broadway St
Shelbyville, IN
Pizza
Create Your Own Pizza
$10.79+
Pepperoni Pizza
$10.79+
Sausage Pizza
$10.79+
Cheese Pizza
$10.79+
Create Your Own Pan Pizza
$17.99
Exclusive
The Works Pizza
$13.79+
The Meats Pizza
$13.79+
Super Hawaiian Pizza
$13.79+
Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza
$12.99+
Bbq Chicken Bacon Pizza
$13.79+
Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza
$13.79+
Philly Cheesesteak Pizza
$13.79+
Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo Pizza
$13.79+
Garden Fresh Pizza
$13.79+
Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza
$13.79+
Create Your Own Gluten-Free Crust
$11.99
Exclusive
Hawaiian Bbq Chicken Pizza
$13.79+
New York Style Crust
$13.29+
Sandwiches
Chicken Bacon Ranch Oven-Toasted Sandwich
$9.99
Exclusive
Philly Cheesesteak Oven-Toasted Sandwich
$9.99
Exclusive
Steak & Mushroom Oven-Toasted Sandwich
$9.99
Exclusive
Wings
Unsauced Roasted Wings
$10.39+
Garlic Parmesan Wings
$10.39+
Buffalo Wings
$10.39+
Bbq Wings
$10.39+
Honey Chipotle Wings
$10.39+
Unsauced Boneless Wings
$10.39+
Garlic Parmesan Boneless Wings
$10.39+
Buffalo Boneless Wings
$10.39+
Bbq Boneless Wings
$10.39+
Honey Chipotle Boneless Wings
$10.39+
Sides
Cheesy Garlic Bread
$5.99
Exclusive
Garlic Knots
$8.29
Exclusive
Original Breadsticks
$8.29
Exclusive
Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks
$8.79
Exclusive
Cheesesticks
$11.69
Exclusive
Bacon Cheesesticks
$12.39
Exclusive
Tuscan 6-Cheese Cheesesticks
$12.39
Exclusive
Papa Bowls
Create Your Own Papa Bowl
$9.69
Exclusive
Desserts
Cinnamon Pull Aparts
$9.49
Exclusive
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$8.79
Exclusive
Double Chocolate Chip Brownie
$9.19
Exclusive
Drinks
Pepsi
$2.99+
Mountain Dew
$2.99+
Aquafina
$2.99
Exclusive
Pepsi Zero Sugar
$2.99+
Starry
$2.99+
Dr. Pepper
$2.99+
Dipping Sauces
Special Garlic Sauce
$0.99
Spicy Garlic Sauce
$0.99
Original Pizza Sauce
$0.99
Ranch Sauce
$0.99
Blue Cheese Sauce
$0.99
Buffalo Spicy Sauce
$0.99
Barbeque Sauce
$0.99
Cheese Sauce
$0.99
Cream Cheese Icing
$0.99
Extras
Special Seasonings
$0.39
Crushed Red Pepper
$0.39
Parmesan Cheese
$0.39
Pepperoncinis
$1.00
Jalapeño Peppers
$1.00
Banana Peppers
$1.00
Anchovies
$1.00
Frequently asked questions
What are Papa Johns Pizza's hours?
Papa Johns Pizza is open: Monday-Thursday 10am-12am; Friday-Saturday 10am-1am; Sunday 10am-12am.
Where is Papa Johns Pizza located?
Papa Johns Pizza is located at 510 E Broadway St, Shelbyville, IN 46176.
How do I contact Papa Johns Pizza?
Call Papa Johns Pizza at (317) 398-2600 for questions about your order, hours, or directions.
Does Papa Johns Pizza offer delivery?
Yes — you can order delivery directly from Papa Johns Pizza on Bites, with no price markup and no hidden fees.
Can I order pickup from Papa Johns Pizza?
Yes — order pickup from Papa Johns Pizza at 510 E Broadway St, Shelbyville, IN 46176.
Are there hidden fees or price markups when ordering Papa Johns Pizza on Bites?
No — Bites lets you order directly from Papa Johns Pizza with no menu markup, no hidden service fees, and no commissions taken from the restaurant. You pay the same prices you would in-store.
🥘🍔🍛🍜🌯🍕